Free Ebooks

comments from reviewers

Sample Response to Reviewers APA Style

Reviewers' Comments to the Authors Reviewer 1 There are numerous strengths to this study including its diverse sample and wellinformed hypotheses Author response Thank you! 1 Comment from Reviewer 1 noting a mistake or oversight in the manuscript Author response Thank you for pointing this out The reviewer is correct and we have

Importing and exporting comments Adobe Acrobat

In some instances reviewers make comments in a PDF that was created from a Microsoft Word document You can revise the original Word document by exporting these comments from the PDF

How to handle reviewer's comment on grammatical mistakes

The comment form one of the reviewer I got is "The English in the present manuscript is not of publication quality and require major improvement Please carefully proof read spell check to

Reviewer Comments and Responses

Reviewer Comments and Responses Reviewer 1 comment Comment This was an excellent report on very thorough research The literature review was thorough the methodology was painstakingly thorough and incorporated the use of sufficient numbers of samples in dust size analysis and explosion tests There was clear scientific and

Reviewers' comments Nature Research

Reviewers' comments Reviewer #1 (Remarks to the Author) The authors have used ps laser to make nanoparticles on silver surface so that different visible colors can be realized due to the light absorption of nanoparticles with different sizes on the surface First as the authors agreed the original idea of making such color pattern on metal

Reviewer Comments to Author(s) Reviewer #1 (Jillon Vander

Reviewer Comments to Author(s) Reviewer #1 (Jillon Vander Wal PhD) Overall this is a clear concise and well written manuscript The introduction is relevant and theory based Sufficient information about the previous study findings is presented for readers to follow the present study rationale and procedures


How to write a reviewer report 4 5 Tips for preparing a reviewer report For the evaluation of the paper a reviewer's report form is provided on the online reviewing system for you to fill in dealing with the appropriateness of the presentation and scientific quality of the paper

How to respond to comments by peer reviewers Editage Insights

Comments from peer reviewers more often than not offer an excellent opportunity to improve the quality of your manuscript Addressing them adequately may increase the chances of acceptance if not in that journal elsewhere at least

Reviewer comments and how to respond International Science

Sep 06 2016 · Reviewer The English is not good enough for publication Author Some of the reviewer's comments were so badly written how can he be a good judge of English! It's true that many reviewers do not have English as their first language

Response to Reviewers Comments Response to Reviewer # 1

Response to Reviewers Comments We thank the reviewers for their thoughtful and supportive comments We have revised our manuscript in response to their suggestions and hope that this improved manuscript is acceptable for publication in SOIL Response to Reviewer # 1 Comment Minor comments are (i) acknowledging the fact that most of these

A template for responding to peer reviewer comments

Comments from Reviewer 1 Comment 1 Paste the first comment here and italicize it Response Type your response here unitalicized List the other comments for this section in the same format Comments from Reviewer 2 Comment 1 Paste the full comment here and italicize it Response Follow the patterns recommended above

Top 10 Tips for Responding to Reviewer and Editor Comments

Apr 01 2011 ·

How to remove reviewers names from comments Microsoft

Tech support scams are an industry wide issue where scammers trick you into paying for unnecessary technical support services You can help protect yourself from scammers by verifying that the contact is a Microsoft Agent or Microsoft Employee and that the phone number is an official Microsoft global customer service number

Responding to editor decision letters and reviewers' comments

Responding to editor decision letters and reviewers' comments In the vast majority of cases papers will require at the very least some further changes or review based on the feedback from the journal editor and reviewers it is very rare that journals accept articles without any amendments from the author(s)


0037) The review process is now complete and three thorough reviews from highly qualified referees are included at the bottom of this letter Although the reviewers found considerable merit in your paper they also identified some concerns Therefore I invite you to respond to the action editor and reviewer(s)' comments and revise your

Starting a PDF review Adobe Acrobat

The reviewers receive an email invitation with a link to the review PDF When they click the link or the Review button in the invitation the PDF opens in a web browser They can use the commenting tools to add comments to the PDF

How to View Specific Reviewers' Comments and Edits in

7 Return to Specific People in the Show Markup drop down menu and select All Reviewers to show everyone's comments and edits Use Navigation to View Comments from Specific Reviewers If you only need to view specific reviewers' comments (not edits) use the Navigation pane to quickly move through the document

Reviewers Comments and Authors Response

Reviewers' Comments and Authors Response Paper number ADHOC D 13 37 Paper title Reverse Back off Mechanism for Safety Vehicular Ad Hoc Networks Authors R Stanica E Chaput and A L Beylot The authors would like to thank the area editor and the reviewers for their precious time and invaluable comments

The Joy of Peer Review or My Favorite Comments from Editors

The Joy of Peer Review or My Favorite Comments from Editors and Reviewers Comments in blue are exact quotes Black is for additions comments or paraphrasing by me The page was inspired by a similar page made by Butch Brodie III at Indiana University The Funny Some things probably should not be said whether you think them or not

Reviewing comments from the specific reviewer Microsoft

To find a specific reviewer's comment select that reviewer's name from the Enter Reviewer's Name drop down list The names of all reviewers who have added comments to the document appear on this list To find a specific comment enter the number of that comment (without the reviewer's initials) in the Enter Reviewer's Name text box

Sample Employee Evaluation Comments Performance Review

Sample Evaluation Comments Performance reviews and appraisals are very simple which is why we like to provide you with free examples you can use for your company These will help save you time while still providing quality feedback to your employees

How to export comments from reviewer and responses Adobe

Jun 27 2017 · Thanks try67 but as a result Based on the original document appended additional comments summary page for each original page not a standalone comments summary please refer to attached screenshot what we want is one excel file with all comments from reviewer and all responses from author

3 top tips for responding to reviewer comments on your manuscript

3 top tips for responding to reviewer comments on your manuscript An editor and publisher highlight the dos and don'ts when providing feedback By Lucy van Hilten Posted on 12 February 2015 Peer review has a vital role to play in research and publishing and a key step in that process is the revision of your paper

General Comments from the Reviewers General Comments from

General Comments from the Reviewers General Comments from Reviewer 1 Comment This is an interesting study and the authors have collected a unique dataset using cutting edge methodology The paper is generally well written and structured However in my opinion the

How to Respond to Reviewer Comments on Your Manuscript Wordvice

Use formal language in all responses to the reviewers' comments Be sure to set the right tone in your rebuttal letter Responding with anger or outward criticism of the reviewer's comments certainly won't win you any favors with the journal Avoid taking a strong or argumentative tone if you happen to disagree on any issues

12 Unimpressed Comments From Peer Reviewers IFLScience

Dec 14 2014 · 12 Unimpressed Comments From Peer Reviewers 0 Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Editor's Blog iQoncept / Shutterstock By Kristy Hamilton 14 Dec 2014 16 36

PEER REVIEW REPORT Responses to Comments from

Comments from individual reviewers were itemized and numbered to facilitate specific responses In some cases where appropriate responses to some comments were explanations for

How to respond to reviewer comments the CALM way

Apr 03 2019 · Organise your responses by listing each of the reviewers' comments and addressing each one separately below Resist the trap of lazy responses like "answered" or "fixed in manuscript" Be clear about how you responded (copy and paste the updated text below the reviewers' comments) and state where this fits into the manuscript (with

How to Write Helpful Peer Review Comments Scholastica

Additionally Matt Might reminds reviewers to keep snarky comments to themselves as the presence of sarcasm in peer review may nullify any useful feedback you've provided in the eyes of the author Give concrete examples and advice Be sure to backup your peer review comments and opinions with concrete examples and suggestions for improvement

Answers to Reviewer #1 comments

Answers to Reviewer #1 comments We thank the reviewer for the constructive comments on the manuscript We will detail in our response below how we plan to address the reviewer comments General comments 1) The paper is quite long and it contains many figures (17 3) and analyses The intercomparison